This is an estimate for planning. It is not a quote, an appraisal, an offer, a loan offer, or tax or legal advice, and Rudy is a real estate agent, not a lender or tax professional.
The five paths, in plain English
Open-market listing
Your home is listed in the MLS and shared with the public home-search sites, then shown with photos, tours and open houses. Every buyer and agent sees it on the same timeline.
When owners often choose it: When the aim is the broadest pool of buyers and a full price test, including buyers who are also touring new homes nearby, and the calendar allows for prep, showings and escrow.
Tradeoffs: Foot traffic through the house goes up, and anyone can see the price history. Prep money is spent before you sell. Once an offer is accepted, escrow tends to take 30 to 45 days. After an inspection, buyers may come back asking for repairs or credits.
Pre-market or Coming Soon
Before any public launch, or in place of one, a smaller set of buyers hears about the home first. That can mean an office-only listing that never leaves one brokerage, a delayed-marketing listing, or Coming Soon status.
When owners often choose it: When privacy, your own say over when and how the home is shown, or room to negotiate terms such as moving out later, outweigh the widest reach.
Tradeoffs: Less exposure can bring fewer offers to weigh and a softer read on price. Coming Soon can run 30 days at most in SDMLS and 21 in CRMLS. No in-person showings happen during it, and a signed form is required first. Zillow’s rule: a publicly marketed home that misses the one-business-day window for the MLS stays off Zillow and Trulia until that listing agreement ends.
As-is or cash offer
Here a buyer pays cash for the home in its present state, often after only one walkthrough. The column runs on the real offer you enter, and the tool doesn’t guess at a discount.
When owners often choose it: When a quicker path with fewer contingencies, and no repairs or showings, matters most.
Tradeoffs: Cash offers often come in below open-market value, because what the buyer brings is speed and certainty, and offers vary from one buyer to the next. Look at who pays which costs. A 1-to-3-week closing is common, though timing depends on the buyer.
Rent it out, sell later
You move on, lease the home to a tenant, and plan the sale for the end of the period you select.
When owners often choose it: If rent would pay a big share of the monthly costs, a later sale suits your plans, or the move may be temporary.
Tradeoffs: Budget for management, by a paid manager or by you, plus repairs and some empty months, and any special tax and HOA dues stay yours while it’s rented. Local rent and notice rules apply. Time as a rental can change your federal home-sale tax exclusion; to qualify, you need 2 years or more of owning the home and living in it during the 5 years ahead of the sale. Your CPA can say how it applies.
Keep the home
Nothing changes hands. You remain in the house as its owner, so there are no selling costs today.
When owners often choose it: If the home still matches your plans, your loan’s terms are worth keeping, or you have no fixed move date.
Tradeoffs: Rather than turning into cash, your equity stays tied up in the home. Loan payments, tax, insurance and upkeep stay on your list. Future value depends on the market, and the growth rate you enter is your estimate, not a forecast.
Pre-market and coming-soon sales: the rules
Early or quiet marketing has to follow several sets of rules at once: national REALTOR® policy, the rules of your MLS and your brokerage’s policy. Home-search sites, Zillow among them, set their own standards on top.
NAR’s Clear Cooperation Policy has not gone away. As soon as a home is marketed to the public, by an email blast, a public website, a flyer, a yard sign or a multi-brokerage sharing network, the listing broker has a one-business-day deadline to submit it to the MLS. The Multiple Listing Options for Sellers policy, which NAR put in effect on March 25, 2025, gives sellers two other paths, short of a full public listing. A listing with delayed marketing shows up for other agents in the MLS, while public search sites wait for a period the MLS sets. Office-only listings are also filed with the MLS, but they stay hidden from agents at other brokerages and aren’t marketed publicly. Either path starts with a disclosure the seller signs.
Otay Mesa is part of the City of San Diego, in San Diego County, where listings go through one of two systems: the San Diego MLS (called SDMLS) or the California Regional MLS (called CRMLS). Each has its own rules.
With SDMLS, Coming Soon is allowed for a maximum of 30 days. Other MLS agents can see the home, and ads and offers are both allowed, but in-person showings and open houses are not. Coming Soon listings don’t go to public portals, or to IDX feeds, which are how listings appear on other brokers’ websites. After a listing turns Active, it can’t switch back to Coming Soon. For delayed marketing under NAR’s policy, SDMLS uses Active status with publishing to the internet switched off. That status has no time limit and does allow in-person showings.
CRMLS allows Coming Soon for 21 days at most, and the listing then becomes Active on its own. No showings of any type are allowed, even by the listing broker, and ads must clearly say Coming Soon. CRMLS usually distributes Coming Soon listings over IDX and to sites like Realtor.com and Homes.com, but a seller can sign a form, added in 2026, to keep the listing off IDX. A listing that has left Coming Soon can’t reenter it. Delayed marketing isn’t available in CRMLS, which also says a listing left out of the MLS can’t be marketed publicly outside the brokerage.
California sellers mark their MLS choices on C.A.R.’s MLSA (Multiple Listing Service Addendum), updated in September 2025, and a given MLS can require a separate form on top. The NAR disclosure records that the seller knows what they are trading away, such as reaching a wide pool of buyers right away through the MLS.
Zillow sets its rule in its Listing Access Standards. Any home marketed publicly that hasn’t been entered in the MLS after one business day goes unpublished on Zillow and Trulia for the whole of that listing agreement. For a home that is not publicly marketed, Zillow asks for a waiver the seller signs, spelling out the drawbacks.
The rules have been updated several times since 2025, and some brokerages add their own policy. Rudy confirms the MLS and the exact rules for your Otay Mesa home and your dates.
Rules as of 2026-10-30. Sources: NAR: Multiple Listing Options for Sellers; NAR: MLS Clear Cooperation Policy (Policy Statement 8.0); NAR: Multiple Listing Options for Sellers FAQ (May 27, 2025); NAR: Office Exclusive Listings, Pre-Marketing Guidance; SDMLS: DMEL & DMLE: What’s the Difference? (Coming Soon Status, revised July 2026); SDMLS: The SELM Is a Discontinued Form (use the C.A.R. MLSA); CRMLS: Coming Soon Status; CRMLS: Limited Exposure for Coming Soon FAQs; CRMLS: C.A.R. Form MLSA (Multiple Listing Service Addendum) FAQs; Zillow: Listing Access Standards (PDF). Your agent will confirm what applies to your home.
About these numbers
- Everything shown is a planning estimate from your numbers. Think of it as a starting point, not an appraisal, offer or forecast.
- Commission is negotiable, with the final rate written into your listing agreement. These selling costs run on the rates you chose.
- Holding costs, for every month before closing, are the loan’s interest together with property tax, insurance and HOA dues.
- Cash at closing and cash years down the road carry different weight. The rent and keep columns don’t factor in income tax, depreciation or earnings the money could make in the meantime.
- Any tax owed on your gain is outside these numbers. Ask a CPA how the home-sale exclusion fits your case, above all if you plan to rent before selling.
Questions owners ask
I’m buying a new build next. How can this page help with timing?
Use the months boxes. The open-market, pre-market and cash columns each have their own months to close, and every month adds holding costs: interest on what you owe, plus tax, insurance and HOA dues. On the open market, the stretch from an accepted offer to closing is usually 30 to 45 days, on top of prep and time listed. A cash sale often closes in 1 to 3 weeks, but each buyer sets its own timeline. Rudy can help you set those dates beside the builder’s schedule.
Where does Mello-Roos or another special tax go?
Add it, as a monthly amount, to the property tax, insurance and HOA line. The tool then adds your loan interest to that line for every month before a sale closes, and the rent column counts it as well. Your tax bill lists each charge on its own line, which makes it easy to find.
Could I rent my Otay Mesa home out now and sell it later?
The rent column runs that plan for the years you pick and then sells at the end. Rent comes in; vacancy, upkeep, a manager’s fee (enter 0 if you’d manage it yourself), your monthly costs and the loan payment come out. Local rent and notice rules apply. Up to $250,000 of gain can be excluded federally, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, if you have owned and occupied the home for 2 years or more out of the 5 before the sale. Ask your CPA how renting first changes that.
Can buyers tour my home while it’s Coming Soon?
Not in person. SDMLS Coming Soon allows no in-person showings or open houses, though you can advertise the home and accept an offer. CRMLS rules out showings entirely, even by the listing broker, and every ad has to say Coming Soon. If tours matter, the SDMLS version of delayed marketing, an Active listing kept off the internet, does allow in-person showings.
What do I sign before any quiet marketing?
NAR’s 2025 policy calls for a seller disclosure, signed before quiet marketing starts. It records that you understand what you’re giving up or putting off, like reaching many buyers right away through the MLS. In this state, the MLS choice is also recorded on C.A.R.’s MLS addendum (MLSA), and SDMLS and CRMLS each have a Coming Soon form of their own. Rudy goes over each form with you first.
More from Rudy
